| | 2011-12 | Bryan Cohen, Bryson Johnson, Mike Muscala |
| 2010-11 | G.W. Boon, Darryl Shazier, Stephen Tyree |
| 2009-10 | Patrick Behan, Stephen Tyree, Darryl Shazier |
| 2008-09 | None |
| 2007-08 | John Griffin, Darren Mastropaolo, Rob Thomas |
| 2006-07 | Abe Badmus, Donald Brown, Chris McNaughton |
| 2005-06 | Kevin Bettencourt, Charles Lee |
| 2004-05 | Kevin Bettencourt, Charles Lee |
| 2003-04 | Matt Quinn, Roland Webber |
| 2002-03 | Dan Blankenship, Boakai Lalugba |
| 2001-02 | Bryan Bailey, Dan Blankenship |
| 2000-01 | Jake Ramage, Bryan Bailey |
| 1999-00 | Dan Bowen, Brian Muckle |
| 1998-99 | Willie Callahan, Max Wetzel |
| 1997-98 | J.R. Holden |
| 1996-97 | Gordon Mboya, Tom Welch, J.R. Holden |
| 1995-96 | Sekou Hamer, Kevin Wenk |
| 1994-95 | Brian Anderson, Sekou Hamer, Kevin Wenk |
| 1993-94 | Chris Simpson, Raymond Brown |
| 1992-93 | Mike Bright, Paul Olkowski, Russell Peyton |
| 1991-92 | Bill Courtney, Patrick King |
| 1990-91 | Keith Fenton, Bill Courtney |
| 1989-90 | Greg Leggett, Mike Joseph |
| 1988-89 | Mike Butts, John Watson |
| 1987-88 | John Watson |
| 1986-87 | Mark Allsteadt, Steve Schrader, Chris Seneca |
| 1985-86 | Steve Schrader |
| 1984-85 | Jaye Andrews, Eric Hegedus |
| 1983-84 | Ed Sigl, Cal Puriefoy |
| 1982-83 | Ray Moss, Jay Wright |
| 1981-82 | Ray Moss, Deb Okorodudu |
| 1980-81 | Al Leslie |
| 1979-80 | Bob Barry, Pat Flannery |
| 1978-79 | Leonard Klebanoff, Pat Flannery |
| 1977-78 | John Callaway, Tom McNichol |
| 1976-77 | Stephen Oristaglio |
| 1975-76 | Sam Stettler |
| 1974-75 | Tom McLean, Sam Stettler |
| 1973-74 | Paul Kerr |
| 1972-73 | Harvey Carter, Jack Darnall |
| 1971-72 | Harvey Carter |
| 1970-71 | William Peterson, Christopher Riley |
| 1969-70 | Victor Cegles, James Wherry |
| 1968-69 | Edwin Farver, Craig Greenwood |
| 1967-68 | John Murphy |
| 1966-67 | Matt McMonigle, John Rodgers |
| 1965-66 | Larry Kozella |
| 1964-65 | Lorry Hathaway |
| 1963-64 | Don Hester |
| 1962-63 | Tom Johnson |
| 1961-62 | Mike Fadden, Joe Steiner |
| 1960-61 | Dick Kniffin, Joe Steiner |
| 1959-60 | Tommy Thompson |
| 1958-59 | Hal Danzig, Ellis Harley |
| 1957-58 | Ellis Harley, Skip Wieder |
| 1956-57 | Marty Tannenbaum, Skip Wieder |
| 1955-56 | Ben Slavitt, Norm Voorhees |
| 1954-55 | |
| 1953-54 | |
| 1952-53 | |
| 1951-52 | Joe Gallagher, Don Strassner |
| 1950-51 | |
| 1949-50 | |
| 1948-49 | Game Captains |
| 1947-48 | Game Captains |
| 1946-47 | Lou Desci |
| 1945-46 | James Seel |
| 1944-45 | Lou Desci |
| 1943-44 | Frank Burns |
| 1942-43 | George Haines |
| 1941-42 | Ed Glass, Bob Snyder |
| 1940-41 | |
| 1939-40 | |
| 1938-39 | William Lane |
| 1937-38 | William Foltz, Harold Sager |
| 1933-34 | Walter Gilleland |
| 1932-33 | William Smith |
| 1931-32 | James Logan |
| 1930-31 | Norman Ross |
| 1929-30 | Welland Wadsworth |
| 1928-29 | Louis Woodring |
| 1927-28 | Archie Seiler |
| 1926-27 | Stanley McCaskey |
| 1925-26 | Donald Rigg |
| 1924-25 | G.H. Fritzinger |
| 1923-24 | Anthony Wilsbach |
| 1922-23 | C.E. Glass |
| 1921-22 | John Dietrich |
| 1919-20 | Franklin Townsend |
| 1918-19 | Andrew Mathieson |
| 1917-18 | Albert Elliott |
| 1916-17 | L.L. Garner |
| 1915-16 | F.C. Brenner |
| 1914-15 | Joe Gidaniec |
| 1913-14 | Dwite Schaffner |
| 1912-13 | H.V. Fisher |
| 1911-12 | Herman Zehner |
| 1910-11 | John Kurtz |
| 1909-10 | N.I. Craig |
| 1908-09 | Charles O’Brien |
| 1907-08 | Charles O’Brien |
| 1906-07 | James Lose |
| 1905-06 | G.W. Leach |
| 1904-05 | George Cockill |
| 1903-04 | Pat Cheesman |
| 1900-01 | C.H. Elliott |
| 1899-1900 | H.B. Wassell |
| 1898-99 | C.A. Weymouthv
| | 1897-98 | A.A. Smith |
| 1896-97 | R.B. Mulkie |
| 1895-96 | D.H. Elliot |
|
Darryl Shazier
|
| |
John Griffin
|
| |
Kevin Bettencourt
|
| |
Boakai Lalugba
|
| |
Charles Lee
|
| |
Dan Blankenship
|
|
