|
|
| 2012 | Joseph Francis, Tyler Smith, Beau Traber |
| 2011 | Josh Eden, Sean Rafferty |
| 2010 | Josh Eden, Travis Nissley, Jason Vollmar, Marlon Woods |
| 2009 | Greg Jones, A.J. Kizekai, James Phelan |
| 2008 | A.J. Kizekai, Greg Jones, Kevin Mullen, Casey Williams |
| 2007 | Jonathan Grainger, Ryan Slater |
| 2006 | Stefan Niemczyk, Dorian Petersen |
| 2005 | Sean Conover, Stephen Watts |
| 2004 | Kevin Ransome, Daris Wilson |
| 2003 | Tim Johnson, Mike Leatherman |
| 2002 | Gary Carruthers, Adam Lord, Todd Warmington |
| 2001 | Carson Book, Jabu Powell, Mark Tallman, Reed Tunison |
| 2000 | Vince Ficca, Justin Lustig, Lucas Phillips |
| 1999 | Corey Hurley, Dan Palko, John Papadakis |
| 1998 | Erich Muzi, Jeremy Myers, Neal Thompson |
| 1997 | Hunter Adams, Wally Hurdley, Chris Peer |
| 1996 | George Howanitz, Rich Lemon, Brandon Little |
| 1995 | Rob Bird, Brian Gay, John Sakowski |
| 1994 | Ed Frattarelli, Russ Strohecker, Andrew Welty |
| 1993 | Cecil Boone, Travis Kopp, Russ Strohecker, Dan Zappa |
| 1992 | David Berardinelli, John Lusk, Eric Rutter |
| 1991 | Brian Henesey, John Spatafore |
| 1990 | Mike Augsberger, Craig Cavlovic |
| 1989 | Scott Auchenbach, Mark Williams |
| 1988 | Ed Foley, Chris Hackley, Steve Weiss |
| 1987 | Jim Given, Greg Schiano |
| 1986 | Earl Beecham, Doug Fastuca |
| 1985 | Will McFarland, Joe Shupp |
| 1984 | Bob Gibbon, Keith Jansen |
| 1983 | Ron Clark, Brad Henneman, Shane Snyder |
| 1982 | Marty Schaetzle, Mike Thompson, Steve Zenda |
| 1981 | Ken Jenkins, Jeff Miller |
| 1980 | Joseph Catalano, David Hibbard, Bruce Keltie |
| 1979 | John Campana, Mike McDonald |
| 1978 | John Cieslewicz, Mike Cosimano, Brian Shaffer |
| 1977 | Bill Clifford, Dave Devonshuk, Tim Hislop |
| 1976 | Karl Meyer, Jim Nesbitt, Kerry Snow |
| 1975 | Ralph Turri, Rick Wardrop |
| 1974 | Mike Axe, Larry Schoeneberger |
| 1973 | John Dailey, Carl Probst |
| 1972 | Steve Eck, Gerry Solomon |
| 1971 | Joe DiOrio, John Klenovic |
| 1970 | Gene Depew, Don Giacomelli |
| 1969 | Randy Ruger, Dave Vassar |
| 1968 | Sam Havrilak |
| 1967 | Dick Kaufman |
| 1966 | Bob Marks, Mike Vincent |
| 1965 | T. Geoffrey Traub |
| 1964 | John Barron |
| 1963 | Thomas Boyd, William Swineford |
| 1962 | Richard Tyrrell |
| 1961 | Kirk Foulke |
| 1960 | Clifford Melberger |
| 1959 | Larry Mathias |
| 1958 | Charles Apgar, Lewis Hart |
| 1957 | Bob Fitzsimmons, Rogers Frassenei |
| 1956 | Don Koppes, Ralph Riker |
| 1955 | Bob Sierer, Jim Kozlowski |
| 1954 | John Chirona |
| 1953 | Paul Ganz, Bill Gray, Jim Egloff |
| 1952 | Harry McSorley, Abe Powelson |
| 1951 | Robert Albert, Jr., George Young |
| 1950 | Richard Johnson, Arnold Pechulis |
| 1949 | Edward Stec |
| 1948 | John Geosits |
| 1947 | Paul McConnell |
| 1946 | No captain |
| 1945 | Harold Stefl, Robert Williams |
| 1944 | Eugene Hubka, Robert Grant |
| 1943 | Eugene Matthews, Walter Szot |
| 1942 | William Anderson |
| 1941 | Frederick Gore, Melvin Knupp |
| 1940 | Morris Bessel, John Plewak |
| 1939 | George Kiick, Harold Pegg |
| 1938 | William Lane, Louis Tomasetti |
| 1937 | Herbert Bowman, Enio Conti |
| 1936 | John Filer, Stuart Smith |
| 1935 | John Sitarsky |
| 1934 | George Boiston, Ralph Furiell |
| 1933 | Owen James, Nicholas Farina |
| 1932 | Edward Nied |
| 1931 | Cyrus Marter |
| 1930 | Anthony Slate |
| 1929 | Ernie Woernor |
| 1928 | Eddie Halicki |
| 1927 | Wally Diehl |
| 1926 | William Stephens |
| 1925 | Anthony Kostos |
| 1924 | Wally Foster |
| 1923 | Max Reed |
| 1922 | Vic Bihl |
| 1921 | Arda Bowser |
| 1920 | Joe Kostos |
| 1919 | John Hendren |
| 1918 | Robert Waddell |
| 1917 | Boyd Newcomb |
| 1916 | Sidney Peale |
| 1915 | Dwite Schaffner |
| 1914 | Erle Topham |
| 1913 | Wilmon Keiser |
| 1912 | Al Jordan |
| 1911 | Victor Schmid |
| 1910 | James Clarke |
| 1909 | Harry Coulson |
| 1908 | Charles O'Brian |
| 1907 | Chester Niple |
| 1906 | Girton Lenhart |
| 1905 | Charles Cooper |
| 1904 | John Johnson |
| 1903 | George Cockill |
| 1902 | Walter Wilcox |
| 1901 | Frank Stanton |
| 1900 | Frank Stanton |
| 1899 | Hugo Riemer |
| 1898 | Emmanuel Cober |
| 1897 | Emmanuel Cober |
| 1896 | Emmanuel Cober |
| 1895 | William Bunnell |
| 1894 | William Kauffman |
| 1893 | Harvey Smith |
| 1892 | Levi Riggins |
| 1891 | Charles Allen |
| 1889 | Charles Allen |
| 1888 | Charles Allen |
| 1887 | H. Hanson |
| 1886 | -- |
| 1885 | -- |
| 1884 | -- |
| 1883 | Carl Law |
| 1882 | -- |
| 1881 | No captain |
