| Name | Sport(s) | Induction Year |
| Hassen I. Abdellah '80 | Football | 2004 |
| Theodore P. Aceto '89 | Basketball, Baseball | 2000 |
| Robert R. Albert '52 | Football | 1982 |
| Thomas A. Alexander '62 | Football | 2009 |
| Charles W. Allen '92 | Football, Tennis | 1983 |
| Mike Anders '98 | Baseball | 2011 |
| Alexander Anderson '71 | Tennis | 1999 |
| John C. Anderson '05 | Basketball, Football | 1983 |
| Jaye Andrews '85 | Basketball | 1991 |
| Scott D. Auchenbach '90 | Football | 2005 |
| Michael J. Axe '75 | Football | 2007 |
| Stephen W. Baird '72 | Tennis | 1983 |
| Almira S. Baldwin Arnold '94 | Field Hockey | 2008 |
| Stephanie N. Bango '02 | Track & Field | 2012 |
| Robert R. Barry '80 | Basketball | 1989 |
| William C. Bartol 1872 | Teacher | 1987 |
| Dawn M. Becker '85 | Softball | 1997 |
| Robert W. Bickel '79 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2002 |
| Edgar H. Biggs | Athletic Trainer | 1984 |
| Walter A. Blair '07 | Baseball | 1988 |
| Neal Blaisdell '27 | Football | 1998 |
| George T. Boiston '35 | Football | 1982 |
| Arda Bowser '23 | Football | 1979 |
| Arthur L. Brandon '27 | Administrator | 1995 |
| Michael C.L. Bright '93 | Basketball | 2005 |
| Mark R. Brotherton '83 | Soccer | 2006 |
| Rodney A. Brown '83 | Lacrosse | 2009 |
| Margaret L. Bryan | Administrator | 1991 |
| George A. Buckheit '79 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 1986 |
| Michael B. Butts '89 | Basketball | 2000 |
| Joseph J. Buzas '41 | Baseball, Basketball | 1981 |
| Francis J. Carroll Jr. '75 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 1994 |
| Harvey D. Carter '73 | Basketball | 2005 |
| Barbara Castens-Seidell '79 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Lacrosse | 1985 |
| John F. Chironna '55 | Football, Baseball | 1984 |
| George W. Cockill '05 | Football, Baseball, Basketball, Coach | 1984 |
| Charles Cole '88 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2010 |
| William L. Courtney '92 | Basketball | 2007 |
| Edward E. Curran '88 | Wrestling | 2005 |
| Thomas E. Cusick '87 | Lacrosse | 1996 |
| Gabrielle L. Czaja '85 | Track & Field, Cross Country | 2000 |
| Dianne T. Czarnecki '87 | Field Hockey, Softball | 1999 |
| John D. Dailey '74 | Football | 1989 |
| Yetunde Daniels Rubinstein '00 | Track & Field | 2012 |
| Harold M. Danzig '59 | Basketball | 1983 |
| Harry O. Dayhoff '23 | Football, Basketball, Track & Field | 1981 |
| Thomas A. Dean '52 | Football | 1988 |
| William D. Dearstyne '62 | Swimming | 1982 |
| Marjorie A. Deck '73 | Basketball, Field Hockey, Tennis | 1989 |
| John B. Dempsey '34 | Football, Track & Field | 1992 |
| Sara S. Den Besten Collins '96 | Rowing | 2009 |
| Glenn W. (Wally) Diehl '28 | Football | 1980 |
| David P. Domsohn '89 | Soccer | 1999 |
| Hugh Donovan '96 | Lacrosse | 2011 |
| William C. Dorr '62 | Swimming | 1995 |
| William L. Drake '75 | Swimming, Water Polo | 1996 |
| Stanley J. Durtan '73 | Football | 1998 |
| Lee C. Edmonds '79 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2002 |
| Kevin R. Eiben '01 | Football, Baseball | 2012 |
| M. Robert Etzweiler '61 | Golf | 2003 |
| Harold L. Evans | Golf Coach, Pro | 1986 |
| Rose Ewan | Administrator, Tennis Coach | 2010 |
| Mitchell Farbstein '73 | Football, Track & Field | 1991 |
| Nicholas A. Farina '34 | Football | 1985 |
| C. Edwin Farver '69 | Basketball, Lacrosse | 1981 |
| Robert R. Ferraro Jr. '94 | Wrestling | 2004 |
| Lonnie Fertik Williard '83 | Track & Field | 1994 |
| John D. Filer '37 | Football, Basketball | 1986 |
| Lisa M. Fink Povsic '93 | Softball, Basketball | 2003 |
| Pat Flannery '80 | Basketball, Basketball Coach, Baseball | 2011 |
| Kirk Foulke '61 | Football | 2010 |
| B. Kathryn Frazier '82 | Swimming | 1987 |
| Pete Fry '32 | Football, Basketball, Baseball, Track | 1997 |
| Frank S. Funair '40 | Football, Boxing | 1984 |
| Thomas E. Gadd | Football Coach | 2003 |
| Joseph A. Gallagher '52 | Football, Basketball, Track | 1981 |
| Michael J. Geraghty '84 | Track & Field | 2006 |
| Robert J. Gibbon Jr. '85 | Football | 2000 |
| Elisabeth Gibbons '95 | Soccer | 2006 |
| J. Ronald Giordano '63 | Football | 1995 |
| James Given '88 | Football | 2007 |
| William H. Gravely '77 | Track & Field, Basketball | 1998 |
| Susanne Gray Behringer '84 | Lacrosse, Field Hockey | 1996 |
| Benjamin W. Griffith 1899 | Administrator, Baseball, Football | 1980 |
| Jay Gross '93 | Swimming | 2008 |
| Margaret Grunow Conze '93 | Swimming | 2004 |
| Arthur F. Gulden | Track & Field and Cross Country Coach | 2001 |
| George F. Haines '43 | Basketball | 1980 |
| Edward H. Halicki '29 | Football, Baseball, Basketball | 1983 |
| F. Ellis Harley '59 | Basketball, Baseball | 1997 |
| Brian S. Harshman '85 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2003 |
| James B. Harvey '88 | Swimming, Water Polo | 1999 |
| Lawrence K. Hathaway '65 | Basketball | 1993 |
| Samuel C. Havrilak '69 | Football | 1981 |
| Pamela H. Heller Shassian '79 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Lacrosse | 2000 |
| Jill Henry-Feeney '81 | Basketball, Field Hockey, Softball | 1993 |
| Edward J. Hess Jr. '90 | Tennis | 2003 |
| Jeff Hilk '86 | Water Polo, Swimming | 2010 |
| W. Clarke Hinkle '32 | Football | 1979 |
| Tameka A. Hinton '95 | Track & Field | 2005 |
| Jon-Robert Holden '98 | Basketball | 2008 |
| Eugene L. Hubka '47 | Football, Baseball | 1987 |
| Mark D. Hulme '83 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2001 |
| Albert E. Humphreys | Football Coach, Administrator | 1997 |
| George K. James '30 | Football, Baseball | 1979 |
| Owen W. James '34 | Football | 1982 |
| Sidney I. Jamieson | Lacrosse & Football Coach | 2005 |
| Kenneth W. Jenkins '82 | Football | 1987 |
| Michael R. Joseph '90 | Basketball | 2003 |
| Alvin F. Julian '23 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | 1981 |
| Catherine A. Karpuk Seward '77 | Diving | 1993 |
| Richard P. Kaufmann '68 | Football, Wrestling | 1996 |
| Robert C. Keegan '44 | Baseball, Basketball | 1982 |
| George H. Kiick '40 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | 1984 |
| Patrick C. King '92 | Basketball | 2006 |
| Ronald C. Kinsey '66 | Football | 2006 |
| Ann L. Kirwin Anderson '87 | Basketball | 1998 |
| Louis Kissling '71 | Lacrosse | 1987 |
| Kathy Kline Grove '80 | Field Hockey, Lacrosse | 1994 |
| David M. Kucera '85 | Football | 1992 |
| William H. Lane '45 | Football, Basketball, Baseball, Baseball Coach | 1979 |
| Robert A. Latour | Swimming Coach, Administrator | 1985 |
| Harry L. Lawrence '51 | Football Coach | 1983 |
| Richard N. Lemon '97 | Football | 2007 |
| Albert V. Leslie '81 | Basketball | 1986 |
| Dorothy "Bugs" Harvey Lloyd '53 | Field Hockey | 2007 |
| Eugene C. Luccarelli '71 | Football, Baseball | 1991 |
| Kathleen A. Lynch '87 | Swimming | 1998 |
| Paul Maczuzak '68 | Football | 1990 |
| Kurt Manrodt Jr. '39 | Football | 1983 |
| Thomas M. Marchetti Jr. '91 | Wrestling | 2009 |
| Robert L. Marks '67 | Football | 1997 |
| Joseph R. Markulike Jr. '90 | Baseball | 2001 |
| Christopher Mathewson 1902 | Baseball, Football, Basketball | 1979 |
| Jay P. Mathias '35 | University Trustee | 1982 |
| Lynnette McBride '91 | Track & Field | 2010 |
| Harry E. McCormick '04 | Baseball, Football, Track & Field, Basketball, Coach | 1979 |
| Michael P. McDonald '80 | Football | 2002 |
| George L. McGaughey '35 | Football | 1982 |
| James W. McKee '69 | Lacrosse | 1999 |
| Martin H. McKibbin '52 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | 1985 |
| Glenn R. McLaughlin '74 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 1999 |
| Thomas E. McLean '78 | Track, Basketball | 1983 |
| Clifford K. "Mickey" Melberger '61 | Football, University Trustee | 2004 |
| Susan D. Mestier Brauner '74 | Swimming | 1997 |
| Geoffrey B. Miller '76 | Swimming, Water Polo | 1998 |
| Thomas G. Mitchell '66 | Football | 1979 |
| Malcolm E. Musser '18 | Basketball, Football, Coaching | 1979 |
| Bradford J. Myers '53 | Football | 1980 |
| Edward C. Myers '34 | Football | 1979 |
| Jennifer A. Myers Keating '98 | Women's Swimming | 2008 |
| Edward E. Mylin | Football Coach | 1981 |
| J. Douglas Nauman '73 | Football, Track & Field | 1984 |
| Sharon L. Nichols '91 | Softball | 2001 |
| Robert H. Odell | Football Coach | 1988 |
| Peter R. O'Keeffe '72 | Swimming | 1984 |
| Gregory W. Olson '70 | Swimming | 1988 |
| James E. Ostendarp '52 | Football | 1981 |
| R. Lyman Ott '62 | Soccer | 1983 |
| Edward W. Pangburn '15 | Football, Baseball, Trustee | 1981 |
| Judith M. Perry West '90 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2008 |
| Margaret Philleo Ricci '79 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Lacrosse | 2002 |
| John M. Plant | Administrator, Coach | 1982 |
| Tyler O. Prout '00 | Baseball | 2012 |
| Martin A. Quick '39 | Boxing, Football | 1990 |
| David P. Rath '70 | Soccer, Tennis | 1988 |
| Arthur B. Raynor '50 | Soccer, Baseball | 1984 |
| J. Maxwell Reed '24 | Football, Baseball | 1989 |
| William P. Reifsnyder '84 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 1989 |
| Craig A. Reynolds | Soccer Coach, Tennis Coach, Track & Field Coach, Administrator | 2012 |
| Don H. Richards '56 | Baseball | 1985 |
| Robert N. Richards Jr. '74 | Diving | 1985 |
| Richard B. Roush '51 | Baseball, Soccer | 2012 |
| Susan Rowland Miller '89 | Track & Field | 1999 |
| Randall J. Ruger '70 | Football, Baseball | 1982 |
| Richard W. Russell | Swimming and Water Polo Coach | 1997 |
| Thomas H. Sanders '79 | Lacrosse | 2000 |
| Richard J. Sayre '82 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 1991 |
| Thomas M. Scotton '78 | Wrestling | 1983 |
| Scott F. Schulte '81 | Water Polo, Swimming | 1986 |
| Roger J. Schwanhausser '75 | Swimming, Water Polo | 2002 |
| Christopher M. Seneca '87 | Basketball | 1992 |
| Larry M. Schoeneberger '75 | Football | 2001 |
| Christian L. Simpson '94 | Basketball | 2011 |
| John J. Sitarsky '36 | Football, Basketball, Baseball, Football Coach | 1985 |
| James P. Smigie '65 | Swimming | 1980 |
| Harvey F. Smith 1894 | Baseball, Football, Trustee | 1982 |
| Stuart M. Smith '38 | Football | 1980 |
| Carl G. Snavely '33 | Football Coach | 1980 |
| Gary A. Sojka | Administrator | 2006 |
| Stacey Spitko Reeder '88 | Basketball, Softball | 1995 |
| Edwin S. Stebbins '37 | Track & Field | 1997 |
| Katherine E. Steele Peters '96 | Volleyball | 2007 |
| Joseph B. Steiner '62 | Basketball | 1986 |
| Stephen J. Stephanou '38 | Boxing, Football | 1991 |
| Herbert E. Stiefel '52 | Football | 1998 |
| Bruce E. Strasburg '75 | Soccer | 1998 |
| Scott A. Strasburg '77 | Soccer | 1993 |
| Donald W. Strassner '52 | Basketball | 1994 |
| Julie M. Sweitzer Granger '99 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2011 |
| Walter S. Szot '44 | Football | 1993 |
| Burton W. Talmage '55 | Football | 1981 |
| W. Paul Terhes '61 | Football | 1980 |
| E. Jared Thimme '66 | Swimming | 1990 |
| Thomas A. Thompson '60 | Basketball, Baseball, Coach | 1986 |
| Louis V. Tomasetti '40 | Football | 1995 |
| Erle M. Topham '15 | Football, Baseball | 1980 |
| Gary B. Toubman '76 | Soccer | 2004 |
| Bradley N. Tufts | Administrator, Golf Coach | 2000 |
| Ken Twiford '62 | Football, Baseball | 2011 |
| Richard C. Tyrrell '63 | Football, Baseball | 1986 |
| Peter W. vonHoffmann '79 | Lacrosse | 1984 |
| Charles J. Wagner '76 | Golf | 1984 |
| Lynne P. Walshaw '89 | Basketball, Softball | 2000 |
| Jennifer A. Walz Lapioli '89 | Basketball | 1999 |
| Patricia A. Way '94 | Lacrosse, Field Hockey | 2006 |
| John S. Webber '52 | Baseball, Basketball | 1993 |
| Karin I. Wegener Knisely '79 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Lacrosse | 1985 |
| Melissa K. Wharton '98 | Volleyball | 2009 |
| James L. Wherry '70 | Basketball | 1987 |
| David White '83 | Cross Country, Track & Field | 2010 |
| William F. "Bud" Wilkinson '36 | Football, Track & Field | 1992 |
| Stephen P. Winings '74 | Swimming | 2008 |
| Jill W. Wise Smith '89 | Track & Field | 2001 |
| Charles R. Woollum | Basketball Coach | 1995 |
| Andrew R.E. Wyant 1892 | Football | 1979 |
| George B. Young '52 | Football | 1980 |
| Jennifer L. Yuengling-Franquet '93 | Softball | 2009 |
| Justin W. Zackey '94 | Lacrosse | 2005 |
Names in Italics are Initial Inductees
